Plans and Conditions

My wife and I volunteer at the Maple Bay Community Garden.  Every Spring about 20 of us gather to plan what will be planted each year.  All the produce we grow goes to Food Rescue, an organization that distributes food to 70 food pantries and shelters in Northwestern Michigan. 

Last year, our little garden donated 9,300 pounds of fresh organic food to people who are food insecure.  It was a stellar year.  All the stars aligned.  The year before all of our preparing, planting, weeding, watering, and harvesting amounted to less than 7,000 pounds.  In spite of our thorough planning, we ended up with fewer pounds and poorer quality produce—the onions rotted and the beans didn’t flourish. 

What was the difference?  Our volunteer vegetarians and professional planters were no less committed to the task.  We didn’t work any less diligently.  We even had sophisticated capabilities re:  irrigation and composting.  The primary difference between year one and year two was that the conditions changed.  The year before it was too cold too early.  Too hot for too long.  Too much rain one month and too little rain the next month.   In short, the conditions changed.  The soil in which we planted our seeds and the climate that was supposed to nurture our immature plants let us down.  It turns out that all the planning in the world can’t overcome conditions that run unpredictably cold and hot. 

Who knows what next year will bring.  We will have more seasoned volunteers, more substantive expertise, and more sophisticated tools.  We will do whatever we can to create the conditions that will nourish our plants and advance our plans.  All of our preparation and planning, however, may not be enough if the environment pulls a dirty trick or two.  Still, we will do what we can together to grow an abundant crop.

I’m sure by now you have figured out that this post is not going to be about gardening.  It’s simply a metaphor for individual, organizational, and national life.

Contrary to Ayn Rand’s philosophy, I believe that who we are and what we become is shaped not only by our individual choices but also by the conditions in which we are raised. Rand argued that individuals are not helpless products of their surroundings, social circumstances, or backgrounds. Regardless of where they begin in life, she believed, people possess the rational capacity and moral agency to determine their own paths. I agree that agency and choice matter, but I also believe there are limits to the extent individual determination can overcome unequal circumstances. The notion that everyone can simply pull themselves up by their bootstraps ignores the profound advantages some inherit and the formidable obstacles others face. We need look no further than the persistent racial and economic disparities in our society to see how profoundly unequal starting conditions shape unequal opportunities and outcomes. And nowhere are those disparities more consequential than in the education of children, where concentrated poverty can perpetuate the very inequalities we claim to value individual effort in overcoming.

When more affluent families leave a school district or choose alternatives, the remaining public schools can become increasingly concentrated with students experiencing economic hardship. This concentration of poverty creates a compounding disadvantage. Schools face greater demands for academic remediation, counseling, and social services. Families often have fewer financial resources and less flexibility to supplement their children’s education. Schools can have greater difficulty attracting and retaining experienced teachers. And students have less access to the influential parent, professional, and community networks that can open doors to educational and economic opportunities.

None of these circumstances is inevitable, nor does it reflect a lack of aspiration or commitment among less affluent families. But together, they can create an increasingly unequal educational environment. The result is often widening achievement gaps, fewer pathways to higher education and rewarding careers, and a greater likelihood that economic disadvantage will be passed from one generation to the next.  Just like in our garden, conditions change every year.

Over the past 50 years, I’ve worked with hundreds of organizations to develop strategic plans.  The plans are typically well formulated with aspirational vison statements, compelling mission statements, well-defined values and operating principles, and directional goals.  And most have quantifiable and time-bound objectives, tasks, and steps with clear responsibilities and accountabilities.  Those plans often sit on shelves and collect dust unless the organization also focuses on creating the conditions which will make it possible to transform their vision into reality and to achieve the desired outcomes. 

I am currently working with three organizations in that particular circumstance.  They have well-articulated plans, board support for the plans, and staff aligned behind the plans.  What could possibly go wrong?

All of them have one thing in common – significant leadership transitions at the top of the organizations.  In each case, the founder has left or will be leaving.  They also share the uncertainty of changing economic conditions.  Finally, and most importantly, they are all facing cultural challenges that may create conditions that will make it extremely difficult to sustain high performance. 

Organizations inevitably face leadership transitions, both planned and unplanned. We are witnessing a rather extraordinary example of the latter at Nvidia, one of the world’s most valuable corporations. Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s co-founder and CEO for more than 30 years, abruptly resigned last week amid revelations about extramarital relationships, including one with a businesswoman suspected by U.S. intelligence officials of having ties to Chinese intelligence, and another reportedly involving a senior Nvidia executive who reported to him. The controversy has triggered an internal investigation, congressional scrutiny, and a significant decline in the company’s market value. Quite a leadership transition! Whew!

With my three local organizations, the transitions may not be as dramatic as the Nvidia example, but perhaps just as consequential for a community culture that values land protection, meaningful conversations, and housing for unhoused people.  All three organizations have achieved remarkable success and national notoriety.  All three are confronting difficult cultural challenges. 

True to form, I’m suggesting three solutions for all three organizations:  build trust, promote interdependence, and inspire a sense of purpose.  It’s not just a cavalier TIP (Trust, Interdependence, and Purpose); it’s based on 50 years of experience in organizational culture change. In my experience, I have found developing and implementing strategic plans depends on establishing these three condition in order to achieve and sustain high performance.  This TIP is not just a 3-point acronym, it is a solid solution for sustainability.  Without deep trust, a spirit of interdependence, and an aspirational purpose (larger than independent self-interest), the best laid plans seldom bear fruit.

Here’s a bigger TIP.  These three conditions can be defined and measured.  Just as it is possible to measure individual performance or assess how “SMART” your plans are, you can do the same with cultural conditions.  Here are some ways to know that those conditions are working to nurture your goals or undermine them.

Trust:

  • We do what we say (we are credible and dependable).
  • We say what we do (we are honest).
  • We say what we say (we are genuine).
  • We demonstrate understanding of different points of view (we are empathic).
  • We value differences (we are respectful).
  • We give colleagues the benefit of the doubt without abandoning critical judgment.
  • We say what needs to be said, directly, respectfully, and without hidden agendas.
  • We address disagreements and disappointments with the people involved rather than talking around them.
  • We are willing to acknowledge mistakes, uncertainty, and what we don’t know.

Interdependence:

  • We seek ways to help each other succeed.
  • We believe that what we can accomplish together is more than any one person can accomplish on their own.
  • We are collaborative.
  • We openly share information, expertise, relationships, and resources.
  • We offer assistance before being asked.
  • We recognize that other people’s success increases the capacity of the whole organization.
  • We avoid territorial behavior, information hoarding, and competition for recognition.

Purpose:

We understand and communicate WHY the organization exists and whom it serves.

  • We connect individual contributions to the organization’s larger mission.
  • We make decisions based on shared values and principles, not simply convenience, expediency, or personal advantage.
  • We hold one another accountable for both results and the way those results are achieved.
  • We regularly ask whether the organization is making the contribution it aspires to make.
  • We have a service mentality.
  • We aspire to the common good.

Without trust, interdependence is difficult because people protect themselves.  Without interdependence, trust can remain cordial but superficial because people don’t work to help each other succeed. Without purpose, trust and interdependence can become comfortable relationships without sufficient direction or ambition.  And perhaps the most important point: Culture is not what leaders say they value. Culture is what people experience, observe, reinforce, and hold one another accountable for every day.

These TIPs need to be front of mind as we try to repair a badly damaged democracy.   Currently, only 4% of the people have a great deal of confidence in Congress.  Clearly, the dysfunctional divisions between Democrats and Republicans are not being bridged with interdependent attitudes.   And it seems that the primary purpose of most politicians is power.

While I’m hoping that we our well-laid garden plans produce 10,000 pounds of produce for food insecure people next year, I am well aware that conditions outside our control may impact that number.  What I am sure about, however, is that we all trust each other, we are all working in a spirit of interdependence, and our purpose is to help others survive and thrive. Self-interest is not present in our garden culture.  I’m hoping that individuals, organizations and governments will learn from the TIPs and enjoy the Turnips of the Maple Bay Garden Gathering.  May it be so.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Sign up now to get notified of new posts by E-mail

Subscribe
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x